Six Smart Women Discussing Doctor Who

This week Deb, Erika, Liz and Tansy revisit an oft maligned (by Deb) story — “The Daleks’ Master Plan”. There are a few disagreements as to pace, plot, story, Katarina… and while may not all agree on which companion actually clocks in as the official 7th companion in Doctor Who history, we do all agree that Sara Kingdom is a BAMF.

How do you feel about this “epic” adventure? Is it a rambling mess? A beloved Doctor Who romp or BOTH? And what is your preferred method for consuming this phantom of a story? Leave us a comment or send us a tweet and let us know how you feel about Bret, Sara, The Meddling Monk or any one of the other 1,183 plot points in “The Daleks’ Master Plan”?

^D

Happy Things:

Bonus Links:

Comments on: "210 – Asylum of The Daleks’ Master Plan" (7)

  1. Help, Verities!

    The download link gives me episode 209 again! Thrilled as I am about hearing you talk about Silver Nemesis, I;d really rather hear you talk about The Daleks Masterplan. 🙂

  2. PaulE said:

    After meeting Liz at Thought Bubble I downloaded your podcast.

    Just want to say how much I’ve been enjoying it!..

  3. For starters, I’m very pleased that Verity covered this serial. Personally, I believe if we had all the episodes, Daleks’ Master Plan would be thought of highly for its ambition, if not anything else.

    I consumed the serial via Tele-Snaps.

    In series 11 of New Who, we got 10 episodes and a New Year’s Day special with Resolution. Daleks’ Master Plan is 12 episodes. That would satisfy a whole season by today’s Golden Age of Cable television standards. So excuse me for injecting this into the conversation, but of course Sara Kingdom is a companion.

    Again, this conversation of Verity was delightful. And to me, the appearance of the Monk brings this story up a notch.

    • Squibby said:

      If the number of episodes in a season and being on the Doctor’s side is all that makes a companion then its very problematical.

      Jackie Tyler, Osgood, all the supportive courtroom characters in Trial of a Timelord, and the White Guardian are all companions under that definition. Not to mention the 7 and 8 episode series of the Pertwee era that had recurring background characters.

      And of course the Alpha Centauri who, with more episodes than a modern season, has a much greater claim to being a companion than Sara Kingdom.

      Intent and travelling with the Doctor is important. Until The Five Doctors fandom and the BBC did NOT consider The Brigadier a companion. He was considered to be an ongoing background character and the Doctor’s boss. Some fans still don’t count him as a companion.

      • Squibby said:

        I just reread that and aside the typos (dratted tablet) it reads much grumpier than I intended.

        My only point is really that Sara Kingdom was one of many characters who over the 56 years of Doctor Who could have been a companion but wasn’t until recent fandom moves included her in some lists.
        Mike Yates, Savalom Glitz, Wilf (Donna’s grandfather), Sergeant Benton, Alpha Centauri – all in multiple stories and yet one of them are official companions

Leave a Reply to Squibby Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: